Main Menu

Home News Forum Photo Album Tech Wiki Downloads Web Links Polls FAQ Members Map

Fast Search

Slow Search

Google Ad

Revision as of 07:39, 29 March 2013

Rack & Pinion has been adapted to many Datsun 1200s, but the were all one-off, undocumented swaps. Below is some information intended to foster development of the art.

1 Rack And Pinion Overview
2 Gemini Swap
3 Electric Rack & Pinion
4 Considerations
5 General Swap Information
- 5.1 Potential Source Racks
  - 5.1.1 Narrow Enough
  - 5.1.2 Too Wide

Rack And Pinion Overview

Consensus:

NOT recommended for circuit or road racing
Recommended for Drag Racing
Jury's out on how well it works for a street car. Those who have done it report good success, those who haven't say the engineering does not add up. See the Considerations section below

GM Opel-built Holden Barina R&P in Datsun 1200:

Discussions: 
* 1200 steering box rebuild/replace - what options?
* Rack and pinion steering for Datsun 1200

Has anyone ever done it? Yes...

Race cars with front tube frame (custom suspension and steering geometry)
dat383 has fitted rack and pinion steering to a 1200 drag racer
1200 with full Escort front suspension (rack + struts + steering arms matched)
wards fitted a Nissan Micra box to his ute
maddatto is experimentng on a KB Laser fitment
Bob Cooper fitted a Mini rack to his Datsun 1200
Janspeed racing 1200, Mini rack?
discussion

Janspeed 1200 on Ratdat.com
1200 Coupe rally car from UK

There are several Datsun 510s with rack and pinion steering swaps. One uses a rack from a Datsun 200SX. Here's what he did:

Move the engine crossmember back a couple inches (which necessitates changes to the engine mounts)
Weld simple flat brackets to the x-member so the rack can be bolted on
Cut the tie-rod ends and weld them back shorter (make sure you have an expert welder do that). For proper handling, they need to be exactly the same length overall as the A-arm overall lengths
Use a newer steering column that has a flex-joint on the end. He used a 200SX column.

The swap had three u-joints and a fairly big angle from the end of the column to the rack, but he said it works great, much better than the stock 510 steering box. No slop!

Would it be better to cut the steering arms shorter and rethread them for the tie-rod ends?

wards said:

I agree this project is not for a novice , I have changed my approach many times as i have discovered pluses and minuses in my geometry , as with any motorsport catergory it's a compromise to achieve a workable result . My aim is to build in as much adjustability as possible to try to cover all bases .

Gemini Swap

Dat383 used a Holden Gemini (Isuzu) steering rack in front of the crossmember.

Brackets are fabricated and welded to the crossmember. Because this fits to the front of the crossmember, while the Datsun steering was behing the xmember, swap the complete strut/brake/LCA assemblies from left to right.
Shortened the Gemini rack ends and then re-thread them to suit.
The front radius arms needed to have a bend pressed into them to clear the tie rod ends when the suspension is on the bump stops.
Modify the standard 1200 steering colum to suit:
- Cut the outside of the column at the steering box and fabricate a plate out of steel, using the original rubber locator as a guide.
- Drill a hole in the plate the same size as the outer diameter of the column
- Weld the plate to the column.
- With the modified column fitted to the car and the inner steering shaft coming out, make a short steering shaft with two small uni-joints to join the colum and rack together.

Electric Rack & Pinion

Electric Rack & Pinion steering geaboxes can be found in:

Acura NSX (first production car with it)
Honda S2000
Toyota Prius
Toyota RAV4
2004-2009 Chevrolet Malibu
2005-2009 Chevrolet Cobalt
2005-2009 Chevrolet Equinox
2006-2009 Chevrolet HHR
2005-2009 Pontiac G6
2006-2009 Pontiac Torrent
2007-2009 Pontiac G5
2002-2009 Saturn VUE
2003-2008 Saturn ION
Kia Forte EX

A typical design has the electric power module mounted on or connected to the steering column. The rack itself is similar to a manual rack. The power module incorporate an electric motor similar in size to a windshield wiper motor.

By contrast, Honda has the electric assist motor with the steering gearbox instead of on the column.

Considerations

For street cars, it is safety first. For safety, you wish to a small amount of Bump Steer to induce slight understeering. For circuit race cars or rally, you probaly won't win without excellent (and fast) handling. But drag racing vehicles don't need to have "good handling" vehicles -- they just need to go very straight. So steering gearbox swaps are popular on these cars, precise geometry is not important on a drag racer.

To do a steering gear swap "correctly" for proper handling, the following must be done:

Bump Steer

inner dimension: 473mm (18.6") for B110 (about 559mm for B310)

To prevent excessive bump steer the ends of the gearbox linkage (where it meets the tie rod ends) must be equal to or less than the distance between the LCA inner pivots. (compare to inner rod ends on the original drag link).
- No bump steer may contribute to oversteer in some cornering conditions. With race cars this is OK (and racers will tune out excessive oversteer in others parts of the suspension), but a street car wants a slight understeer to help prevent easy spinouts. A typical value is two degrees per metre for the front wheels.
- Excessive bump steer causes the steering wheel to jerk when going over bumps, and to wander left and right while driving
- NOTE: Many factory cars have a bit more bump steer than needed due to engineering compromises.
Most important: The up-and-down relationship of the new gearbox matters. It should be in the same plane as the ends of the Steering Knuckles during actual driving
- Bump steer can be made more toe out in jounce by lifting the rack if the rack is in front of the axle. The reverse applies if the rack is behind the axle. Usually only small adjustments (say 3mm) are required.
- For race cars, the designer may choose to match this to a cornering condition, or something other than "normal driving"

Ackermann steering geometry

For good conering, precise Ackermann steering geometry agles of the steering arms is required. True ackerman is where the steering arms point to the mid-point of the rear axle centerline. This is most important for low-speed cornering.
- This is important for gearbox swaps as well as Strut Swaps

Some race cars use reverse Ackermann geometry to compensate for the large difference in slip angle between the inner and outer front tires while cornering at high speed. The use of such geometry helps reduce tire temperatures during high-speed cornering but compromises performance in low speed manoeuvres.

The good news is: if you use stock Datsun 1200 Steering Arms, the correct Ackermann is already built in. Just keep the toe-in stock and align the rack along the original axis of the cross rod and she'll be golden.

For more information, see wikipedia:Ackermann steering geometry

General Swap Information

Can a junkyard part be modified to work?

Basically, if you can duplicate the original steering geometry, it should work fine. If you can place the rack in the same plane as the original cross-rod (both up/down and forward/backwards).

The key here is the pivot-to-pivot point. If you get a rack smaller than this, you can easily extend the pivot width via spacers/studs -- without modifying/cutting the rack itself.

Pivot width: 473 mm (18.6 inches)

As for the length of the tie rod assemblies (inner + outer tie rods), many seem highly customizable, with long sections of threads that could be shortened without need of re-threading. Many of the inners are 14mm threads, so you can mix-and-match to find a close length. Many use 12mm outer threads, so the stock 1200 outer tie-rods could be re-used.

So which boxes are narrow enough?

Potential Source Racks

It needs to be a Rear-steer box, as the original cross rod is behind the crossmember and there is space there to fit a rack.

Swing of box -- how far does it move from side to side? What is the distance the stock cross-rod traverses? Many racks have a short throw, which will increase your turning circle.

Narrow Enough

Double-check the measurements.

GM Opel-built Holden Barina
Too narrow. Can you space out the inner tie-rods?

Nissan B11 48001-04A01
Overall Length: 1,110mm [283+283+544?]
Side Rod 48521-35A06 (B11/B12/N13/S13)
Length: 283mm
Inner thread: 14*1.5
Outer thread: 12*1.25

1983 Civic
~530 mm pivot to pivot

FIAT X1/9
pivots 20.75"

Too Wide

Convert to center pivot use?

1997 Corolla
~570 mm pivot to pivot

Subaru DL?
~21 inches pivot to pivot
ATSCO 6826 MANUAL
brat, DL, GL, GLF, RX, 1.8, 1.6
1980-1982 SUBARU ALL SUBARU-All Engines
1983-1984 SUBARU ALL SUBARU-All Engines 
1985-1989 SUBARU ALL SUBARU-All Engines
1990-1991 SUBARU LOYALE-All Engines
YUGO YUGO-All Engines (86 - 87) 
YUGO YUGO-All Engines (88 - 89) 
YUGO YUGO-All Engines (90 - 92) 
1980-1987 SUBARU BRAT-All Engines 
A-1 CARDONE Part # 242605 
ATSCO Part # 6826
ACDelco ACS1663

Chevette 1980
25.5 pivots (can it be reduced)?
3.75 turns lock to lock with 6" of rack travel 
1.6" per turn Very very slow
A-1 CARDONE Part # 231602
ATSCO Part # 6805
ACDELCO Part # 3616360