|
|
Browsing this Thread:
1 Anonymous Users
|
|
Re: How do you guys get traction with high hp? And awd anyone? |
|
No life (a.k.a. DattoMaster) 
Joined: 2002/10/28 6:49
From under the Firmament LOL no twiglight effect BS
Group:
Registered Users
|
thanks for the pics, what a sleeper!!!
If I ever get a Z it will be the ugly 2+2 with 103 inch wheelbase and will mod the roof to make it like the 2 seater instead. Also TB48 turbo six for that v8 and 2jz beating all nissan combo :)
Posted on: 2011/11/10 23:06
|
|
_________________
"Australia" is formed by all its geographically listed territories "including" Norfolk, Christmas & Cocos Islands. The word include excludes all else before it therefore you have no legal rights.
|
|
|
Re: How do you guys get traction with high hp? And awd anyone? |
|
Not too shy to talk 
Joined: 2010/11/23 2:23
Group:
Registered Users
|
Quote: jmac wrote: l18-b110 - I keep squeezing the other things in because it is important. Hell I didn't even mention that the wider the tyre the less camber it tends to 'like' - which can be indicative of things.
I didnt bother with camber iether simple because my datsun has no adjustment for that and 2nd I was assuming that the 1200 didnt iether. Quote: jmac wrote:
Of course f1 (or anyone else) is running the widest tyres they can (or what they must run) - you're mis-interpreting what I'm getting at. The reason to run wider tyres is not because they grip better 'per se' - if that's the case I welcome you to get some bob jane australian all rounder tread put on some 265 width tyres, and I'll bring some toyo ra1s around to compare. What I am saying is the _reason_ for the widest tyre possible in a racing situation is to give the opportunity to run the stickiest compound possible, but still get enough tyre life to finish enouh laps between pitstops (or the sprint race distance or whatever). It's not just the width.
Ok for some reason When I read what you wrote im thinking thats what im saying lol. Maybe im not writing it down well enough? or my explanation just plain sucks lol. anyways my discussion is based off the same manufaturer/model. Comparing two different tire brand/model is like comparing apples and oranges. you wont accomplish much. What im trying to say is let say you have a gforce ta drag radials. Im picking this in particular because I know two tires from them are are very close in spec. 275/60/15 31lbs 28"diamter thread width 9" 325/50/15 32lbs 27.9"diamter Thread width 10.8" Both will fit in a 9.5" rims so the overall weight and diamter is pretty close. (I dont know any tires that has the same spec in different width) what im saying is under these two option, IF your car has enough power that your having traction issues with 275 then going to a 325 will give you more traction. im ofcource saying that the wider tire will only be beneficial if you have enough power that you reach the limit of the smaller one. if you havent then whats the point of going wider? ofcource wider isnt always better. the smallest ones you can get away with is always best. Quote: jmac wrote:
If you wouldn't mind (and I ask this sincerely, not as a smartalec) - do you happen to have pyrometer readings for the tread - possibly - outer and inner edges and centre region - for the tyres you ran that had the big difference before and after. It'd be interesting to see the spread of temp - both from before and after different tyres, but also to know what temps they ran across the width of the tread, it might be enlightening (to me, if no-one else)
What I was trying to get at, and I'll re-state it (and I know you've said that you would go along with this, and as such we are both sort of talking about two slightly different but related tangents) tread compound is the big deal. It's (relatively) hard to overheat tyres on the street, in most parts of this country, and I can't speak for elsewhere, you'd probably end up getting arrested if you drove hard enough and long enough to overwhelm the tyres. Brake pads - well it'd be relatively hard to overcook a1rms with a bit of touring on twisty roads, but certainly possible on a circuit.
none of that, the comparison wasnt technical it was more result comparison. I simple got more traction with wider tires lol. I agree on a street car its very unlikely that it will be pushed to its limit. but at that mediocre level of heat and such wider tire will give you more traction. (with what I mentioned above) Quote: jmac wrote: I'm DEFINITELY not advocating running 155 width tyres or anything. I hope I haven't come across like that. Perhaps I'll restate it better thusly - width isn't 'all that' I'm not saying run bicycle tyres, but find the specific brands in the wider sizes that have a good track record, it will make or break the deal. There's (unfortunately) seemingly no shortage of tyres available that are 'big' that are also very mediocre as far as grip is concerned.
the same thing applies to brake pads. 'larger' pads, which wrap further around the disc, don't stop better, unless you are reaching the temp limits of the smaller pads. (*if the pad material is the same). The same is true of brake shoe width. IF you are getting them quite hot, then sure, wider is better, but for single stops (or a handful of multiple stops) it won't change things. NOW bigger diameter discs, same pads, definitely improve things, because then they get more leverage.
and one more thing - that's a wicked machine mate.
I agree wich is why my comparison was about the same model of tire. Obviously were talking about the good quality otherwise that would be the first upgrade(to a good quality one lol) thats like asking whats the best size for drag racing on the track and comparing drag radials size when you can run slicks. I dont know if you can compare brake pads since the contact is pretty much controlled(ae metal to metal-no debris) and thanks I hope I made sence of what im trying to say.
Posted on: 2011/11/10 18:11
|
|
|
|
|
Re: How do you guys get traction with high hp? And awd anyone? |
|
No life (a.k.a. DattoMaster) 
Joined: 2008/10/10 22:02
From Melbourne Australia (and likely under the car)
Group:
Registered Users
|
l18-b110 - I keep squeezing the other things in because it is important. Hell I didn't even mention that the wider the tyre the less camber it tends to 'like' - which can be indicative of things.
Of course f1 (or anyone else) is running the widest tyres they can (or what they must run) - you're mis-interpreting what I'm getting at. The reason to run wider tyres is not because they grip better 'per se' - if that's the case I welcome you to get some bob jane australian all rounder tread put on some 265 width tyres, and I'll bring some toyo ra1s around to compare. What I am saying is the _reason_ for the widest tyre possible in a racing situation is to give the opportunity to run the stickiest compound possible, but still get enough tyre life to finish enouh laps between pitstops (or the sprint race distance or whatever). It's not just the width.
I _did_ definitely mention that a bigger tyre won't overheat as quickly. I also mentioned at the start of the post that I was simplifying things a bit to get a point across. If you want to discuss hysteresis (which I probably mis-spelt) and how friction co-efficient actually drops off *(albeit marginally in contrast) with downforce, go for it. I'm not in any way taking this personally, and am happy to discuss it at any length. I'm also not perfect, by any measure, so take anything I say on that basis too!
If you wouldn't mind (and I ask this sincerely, not as a smartalec) - do you happen to have pyrometer readings for the tread - possibly - outer and inner edges and centre region - for the tyres you ran that had the big difference before and after. It'd be interesting to see the spread of temp - both from before and after different tyres, but also to know what temps they ran across the width of the tread, it might be enlightening (to me, if no-one else)
What I was trying to get at, and I'll re-state it (and I know you've said that you would go along with this, and as such we are both sort of talking about two slightly different but related tangents) tread compound is the big deal. It's (relatively) hard to overheat tyres on the street, in most parts of this country, and I can't speak for elsewhere, you'd probably end up getting arrested if you drove hard enough and long enough to overwhelm the tyres. Brake pads - well it'd be relatively hard to overcook a1rms with a bit of touring on twisty roads, but certainly possible on a circuit.
It's not so much I'm getting 'tied up' with theory, but rather I'm just as interested *(if not more) in the why, than just the 'what'. I first came across the whole idea as a teenager - when I was playing mostly with toranas (which are understeering pigs in std form, due to the engine location and polar moment of inertia issues, not that I had any idea of what that meant at the time). I ran 205/60 13s on the almost 'mandatory' sprintmaster mag wheels that are so well linked to the vehicle. I then had a set of wider wheels and ran (and I forget - I think it was bf goodrich, or it might have been bridgestone) 235/50 13s. Then I got a set of 185/60 13s given to me - a set of yokohama a008s (remember this is like 20+ years ago, they were 'something' back then - there were also the a008R which were a softer compound again.. What I really wasn't expecting (I just ran them because I had them sort of thing) was how much better the damn things gripped than the other larger tyres. I didn't manage to overcook them on the street, but I also have to be fair and say I didn't push the cars relentlessly or anything, a few quick squirts here and there.
It wasn't until years later that I got some of the books mentioned, that it started to become clearer to me. And I did my best to apply it. I previously tried more and more neg camber on the torries, but it was rapidly diminishing returns (not to mention braking started to be affected). If I get another torana, engineer willing, I'll relocate the motor rearward somewhat. Not only will it improve entry understeer, but ironically they also have trouble out of corners - not polar moment of inertia related, but rather just a lack of downforce (relative % of the cars weight on the rear tyres)
I'm not saying tread compound is the 'only thing in the universe' but I am suggesting it is the prime consideration.
I'm DEFINITELY not advocating running 155 width tyres or anything. I hope I haven't come across like that. Perhaps I'll restate it better thusly - width isn't 'all that' I'm not saying run bicycle tyres, but find the specific brands in the wider sizes that have a good track record, it will make or break the deal. There's (unfortunately) seemingly no shortage of tyres available that are 'big' that are also very mediocre as far as grip is concerned.
the same thing applies to brake pads. 'larger' pads, which wrap further around the disc, don't stop better, unless you are reaching the temp limits of the smaller pads. (*if the pad material is the same). The same is true of brake shoe width. IF you are getting them quite hot, then sure, wider is better, but for single stops (or a handful of multiple stops) it won't change things. NOW bigger diameter discs, same pads, definitely improve things, because then they get more leverage.
and one more thing - that's a wicked machine mate.
Posted on: 2011/11/10 9:15
|
|
_________________
John McKenzie
|
|
|
Re: How do you guys get traction with high hp? And awd anyone? |
|
Not too shy to talk 
Joined: 2010/11/23 2:23
Group:
Registered Users
|
Quote: D wrote: I want a better picture of this V8Z any chance we can have a few more uploaded to perv on?
I dont usually post pics of my ride but seeing that Im selling it soon ill post it lol. the flare is black now that was a temp paint.  
Posted on: 2011/11/10 4:28
|
|
|
|
|
Re: How do you guys get traction with high hp? And awd anyone? |
|
Not too shy to talk 
Joined: 2010/11/23 2:23
Group:
Registered Users
|
Quote: Rallytwit wrote: At the risk of over simplification: fit the widest stickiest tires you can for pure grip. The too much power for a light car kinda doesn't really hold water for me.................Brabham BT45 (I think) F1 car, 1200lbs and 1200 horsepower in qualifying trim didn't have this issue becuase it features massive slicks that were up to temp, a street car is not going to have heat in the tires at a level you get at the track...................which brings me to why I don't get the whole street racing thing. Dirty tarmac cold tires etc.................what's the point.
Now you can optimize the suspension and run the best tire possible. There are all sorts of things you can do with damper setting and suspension geometry and tire pressures etc to get more out of a car etc. The notion that a light car can have to much power is silly..........................focus on getting the power to the ground, if you don't want to run the best set up for this, then yes wheel spin is going to be a by product.
Tom
Thats pretty much the point of this post lol to figure out what I need to do. BUT the best set up is drag set up which would make a car sloppy on the streets so I cant have that. What im after is a balance between the two. Im not after some hard cornering but I also dont want to be a grandma driving this thing every time i have to take a decent turn or like going on a freeway on ramp. and I think you dont get it cuz its not for you. think of it this way A LOT of people dont get wtf we mod cars either in their eyes "whats the point?". different things work for different people. btw im no way encouraging street racing, but i do my fare share of back road racing. and I do my fare share of mountain runs on motorcycle. Im sure people also dont get that to lol
Posted on: 2011/11/10 4:24
|
|
|
|
|
Re: How do you guys get traction with high hp? And awd anyone? |
|
Not too shy to talk 
Joined: 2010/11/23 2:23
Group:
Registered Users
|
Quote: unfamilia wrote: And none of them really effective in our country for speeds below 110kmh- not really practical here- but neither is an awd system either
I agree aero stuff are nice but were talking traction off the line. and well alot of things arent practical but we love to have them anyways lol
Posted on: 2011/11/10 4:12
|
|
|
|
|
Re: How do you guys get traction with high hp? And awd anyone? |
|
No life (a.k.a. DattoMaster) 
Joined: 2002/10/28 6:49
From under the Firmament LOL no twiglight effect BS
Group:
Registered Users
|
I have to say the wider the tyre is not always right no matter the compound if it doesnt suit the right application. Ive experienced better handling on narrower tyres than wider on certain suspension setups and then wider tyres suiting others. It all depends on the conditions and if there is dust or dirt into the equation then he might even need rallye tyres! Formula one and drag cars are nothing like dirty roads or a dirty backstreet drivers doing illegal drag racing! Should we really be helping this? is the real matter!!!!
There are too many variables and a bit of research helps. Its good if you can find your best combo or tyre and suspension and when you do, it might just not suit somebody else`s driving style or feel. As long as its what you prefer nothing else matters.
Posted on: 2011/11/10 4:12
|
|
_________________
"Australia" is formed by all its geographically listed territories "including" Norfolk, Christmas & Cocos Islands. The word include excludes all else before it therefore you have no legal rights.
|
|
|
Re: How do you guys get traction with high hp? And awd anyone? |
|
Not too shy to talk 
Joined: 2010/11/23 2:23
Group:
Registered Users
|
Quote: jmac wrote:
On wet surfaces - I'll have to beg to differ. wider is _not_ always better. The problem is that the wider the tyre, the greater the volume of water it has to shift out of the way, and the further it has to shift it, so the tyre can grip. So once you go beyond a certain width (and it's a lot narrower than what would be 'useful' on a dry tyre overall) the tyre will actually be MORE likely to aquaplane.
You also have to look at the unsprung weight. That can (admittedly) be an advantage in some places, not always, but it's possible. It also depends on how much of an excess of power there is. I remember a website did a very tongue in cheek 'before and after' writeup where they kept modifying things on a car, a stock low-performance import of some description, and ran it down the 1/4mile. One of the first things they did was to remove the big diameter bling wheels and tyres and re-fit the stockers, and despite the stockers being less grippy, the motor just wasn't that powerful (it was running 18 seconds or so iirc) and they improved the time by a few tenths just with the stock wheels/tyres.
Back on the original topic though - when I mentioned suspension setup being vital, it is possible to get a good combination that is reasonable off the line and also through corners. And it _is_ possible (if the suspension geometry/particulars happen to cross over a certain point) to actually be too low for cornering to be optimal.
Last but not least - you could also look at (relatively simple) stuff like having different boost/timing curves that are switchable based on what gear you are in. In some drag racing, they have different timing curves for each gear, not so much as traction control (which is the way I'm suggesting it for helping traction) but rather the fact that the engine is cooler off the line, so more timing is safe/desirable, but toward the end of the 1/4mile with heat soak, chamber and piston surface temps are higher and less timing is both more optimal for power, but also necessary to avoid engine damage.
I think you took that statement to a bit extreme. Im not saying at all that bigger is always better and yes you are correct eventually too big of a tire will slow down your ride IF AND ONLY IF you didnt need them to begin with. whats the point of slapping on a 275 if you car has full traction at 225. but if your cars only get traction with 275 then it would be optimal to run it. and in regards to wet surface. I dont know squat about f1 cars or what not but its not something I want to use for comparison since its way to much power and way to wide tires. im basically saying on your average tire I would rather have 255 tires on the rain vs 215 or 195. were talking streets. this is what im talking about and dont forget were still talking datsun 1200 here so I dont see anyone putting 275 all around on this thing.
Posted on: 2011/11/10 4:07
|
|
|
|
|
Re: How do you guys get traction with high hp? And awd anyone? |
|
No life (a.k.a. DattoMaster) 
Joined: 2002/11/26 0:38
From Las Vegas USA
Group:
Registered Users
|
At the risk of over simplification: fit the widest stickiest tires you can for pure grip. The too much power for a light car kinda doesn't really hold water for me.................Brabham BT45 (I think) F1 car, 1200lbs and 1200 horsepower in qualifying trim didn't have this issue becuase it features massive slicks that were up to temp, a street car is not going to have heat in the tires at a level you get at the track...................which brings me to why I don't get the whole street racing thing. Dirty tarmac cold tires etc.................what's the point.
Now you can optimize the suspension and run the best tire possible. There are all sorts of things you can do with damper setting and suspension geometry and tire pressures etc to get more out of a car etc. The notion that a light car can have to much power is silly..........................focus on getting the power to the ground, if you don't want to run the best set up for this, then yes wheel spin is going to be a by product.
Tom
Posted on: 2011/11/10 2:51
|
|
|
|
|
Re: How do you guys get traction with high hp? And awd anyone? |
|
|
Guest_
|
And on the same basis the cars and examples given of f1 and top fuelers are at the other extreme of the power scale where they want maximum grip for their intended purpose. 300hp shouldn't need to go to these extremes but in a light car with more power than originally designed for traction will be an issue no mater what
Posted on: 2011/11/10 1:30
|
|
|
You can view topic.
You cannot start a new topic.
You cannot reply to posts.
You cannot edit your posts.
You cannot delete your posts.
You cannot add new polls.
You cannot vote in polls.
You cannot attach files to posts.
You cannot post without approval.
|