Two very different applications here though....
I suspect the tyre contruction and contact patch has a lot to do with it. If you look at a shellsport car on 13x10's, the diameter of the tyre is about 20 inches (or less than the original 12 inch!!)
The contact patch is therefore about 2 inches long, and 10 wide, and remember these are crossply slicks... You only ever run very conservative suspension angles to make these things work, so you dont end up working them very hard, the tyre doesnt tip over much with steering input......
Now looking at a car running on modern radials, the contact patch is probably something like 4 inches long, and 6 inches wide... You run huge camber and castor to make them work, which tips the tyre all over the show! Prap's adding scrub to this equation just stuffs things up too much....
I suspect that for any given setup, less scrub will always work better, if it's technically possible, which it isn't if you're stuck with Macpherson struts....