My experiences have been good with phils. I bought 3 120y rear window seals, one 1200 gearstick boot and one 120y front windscreen seal. I have a genuine nissan front rubber I was going to compare it to and dry fit to the coupe when I get that dam snake out of my shed. Also with the gear boot it's tight on the stick but loose on the 120y plate it's supposed to be grommoted into due to not having enough lip in the grommet. I used contact adhesive to hold the top lip onto the plate but I'm hoping they can do something about it with future batches.