Quote:
Ronald wrote:
Quote:or is everyone afraid of high pressure spooky gas...
i think thats it!
people are affraid that natural gas is too dangerous to be used comercially...... i say go back to school hippy.
same as hydrogen: it just sounds dangerous doesnt it?! yet a tank of hydrogen is less explosive than a tank of petrol.
Quote:
B210sleeper wrote:
people have a perceived safety thing with their petrol tanks. the metal is so thin you could put a steak knife through it. Many auto manufacturers have had problems with bolts making holes in petrol tanks. LPG tanks are very thick, and with the internal pressure it takes a lot to puncture. Properly engineered lpg systems are safer too.
Call me stupid but I dont see how you can say a tank of hydrogen is less explosive than a tank of petrol.
Having worked with cars and batteries, I know how explosive both petrol and hydrogen are.
Now I dont know how hydrogen is stored. Whether its stored as a gas or as a compressed gas becoming liquid like lpg. But I do know it is very explosive.
Now lets face it, if either hydrogen, lpg or petrol are stored correctly, there is little danger of explosions. But its the automotive part of the storage that is the bad part.
Cars crash allday everyday.
I have seen the result of a car crash inwhich a lpg tank has exploded and i have seen the result of car crashes inwhich a petrol tank has been damaged.
The first problems are the tanks. A tank containing a compressed gas has great internal pressure placed upon it. Split it anywhere and it will destroy itself because of the internal pressure ripping it apart. Split a pertol tank and there is far less if any internal pressure affecting the split tank.
Next problem is the combustable itself.
Release a compressed gas and it expands. Release it quickly and it can self ignite. Even oxygen can ignite.
When gas expands, it takes up lots of room and is a big risk of an explosion
Release petrol from a tank and it doesnt expand.
Petrol itself as a liquid isnt that explosive. pour it quickly on a fire and it can put out the fire.
The petrol vapour is highly explosive.
But what is a greater risk a full tank of gas being released into the air or a tank of petrol splashing all over the place.
Both are dangerous, but both lpg and hydrogen are more explosive than a tank of petrol. There is no way it can be said that a tank of hydrogen is less explosive than a tank of petrol.
And although it has been said that a lpg tank is harder to puncture because of the internal pressure., If it is punctured ( not exactly difficult in a car crash) it is the self destructive internal pressures of the tank that make it so bad.
If nobody was to crash and all tanks were efficient, it would be a different story. Fact is people crash, whether by accident or bad driver, it still happens.